The practical guide
Brother vs Singer sewing machines
Brother or Singer? Neither wins across the board. Compare their beginner, computerized and serger models side by side, plus how each warranty works.
Find your machine
Pick the model for the job, then the brand.
The short answer
Neither brand is better across the board, so compare the models that do your job. In our guides, Brother's strength is light computerized machines with quilting extras in the box, like the CS7000X. Singer's is its Heavy Duty line and big stitch libraries, like the 4423 and the Quantum Stylist 9960. For a first serger, both make a good one.
Model by model
Three matchups, each pairing a Brother and a Singer that do the same job. Every figure comes from the maker's own product page.
Simple dial machines: Brother XM2701 vs Singer Heavy Duty 4423
Both use dials instead of a screen. The XM2701 is lighter and includes a narrow hemmer foot; the 4423 adds a metal interior frame, a stronger motor and more speed for denim and canvas.
| Lighter and simpler Brother XM2701 See at Amazon | Stronger and faster Singer Heavy Duty 4423 See at Amazon | |
|---|---|---|
| Built-in stitches | 27 | 23 |
| Buttonhole | One-step, 1 style | One-step |
| Top speed | 800 a minute | 1,100 a minute |
| Build | Six feet in the box, including a narrow hemmer | Metal interior frame, stronger motor |
| Machine weight | 12.6 lb | 14.6 lb |
- Lighter and simpler
Brother XM2701
- Built-in stitches
- 27
- Buttonhole
- One-step, 1 style
- Top speed
- 800 a minute
- Build
- Six feet in the box, including a narrow hemmer
- Machine weight
- 12.6 lb
- Stronger and faster
Singer Heavy Duty 4423
- Built-in stitches
- 23
- Buttonhole
- One-step
- Top speed
- 1,100 a minute
- Build
- Metal interior frame, stronger motor
- Machine weight
- 14.6 lb
Computerized machines: Brother CS7000X vs Singer Quantum Stylist 9960
The CS7000X is the lighter machine with a walking foot and wide table for quilting. The 9960 has far more stitches, lettering and buttonhole styles, and cuts the thread for you, but weighs about 8 pounds more.
| Quilting extras included Brother CS7000X See at Amazon | Biggest stitch library Singer Quantum Stylist 9960 See at Amazon | |
|---|---|---|
| Built-in stitches | 70 | 600 |
| One-step buttonholes | 7 styles | 13 styles |
| Lettering | None | 5 alphabets |
| Top speed | 750 a minute, with a speed slider | 850 a minute, with speed control |
| Extras | 10 feet including a walking foot, wide table, hard cover | 13 feet including a walking foot, extension table, hard cover, automatic thread cutter |
| Machine weight | 10.5 lb | 18.2 lb |
- Quilting extras included
Brother CS7000X
- Built-in stitches
- 70
- One-step buttonholes
- 7 styles
- Lettering
- None
- Top speed
- 750 a minute, with a speed slider
- Extras
- 10 feet including a walking foot, wide table, hard cover
- Machine weight
- 10.5 lb
- Biggest stitch library
Singer Quantum Stylist 9960
- Built-in stitches
- 600
- One-step buttonholes
- 13 styles
- Lettering
- 5 alphabets
- Top speed
- 850 a minute, with speed control
- Extras
- 13 feet including a walking foot, extension table, hard cover, automatic thread cutter
- Machine weight
- 18.2 lb
First sergers: Brother 1034D vs Singer S0100
Both have differential feed and sew up to 1,300 stitches a minute. The S0100 adds 2-thread stitches, a rolled hem set with a lever and a free arm; the 1034D keeps to 3 and 4 threads. Our best serger for beginners guide compares them with a third pick.
| Simplest first serger Brother 1034D See at Amazon | Adds 2-thread stitches Singer S0100 See at Amazon | |
|---|---|---|
| Thread setups | 3 or 4 threads | 2, 3 or 4 threads |
| Rolled hem | Yes | Yes, with a lever |
| Threading help | Color-coded guides, lower looper system | Color-coded paths, lay-in tension dials |
| Free arm | Not yet verified | Yes |
| Machine weight | 13.45 lb | 13.5 lb |
- Simplest first serger
Brother 1034D
- Thread setups
- 3 or 4 threads
- Rolled hem
- Yes
- Threading help
- Color-coded guides, lower looper system
- Free arm
- Not yet verified
- Machine weight
- 13.45 lb
- Adds 2-thread stitches
Singer S0100
- Thread setups
- 2, 3 or 4 threads
- Rolled hem
- Yes, with a lever
- Threading help
- Color-coded paths, lay-in tension dials
- Free arm
- Yes
- Machine weight
- 13.5 lb
How the warranties differ
Both makers advertise 25 years, but that long term covers only part of the machine. Brother's standard US warranty on its sewing machines covers the chassis casting for 25 years, electronic parts and circuit boards for 2 years, and other parts and labor for 1 year. Brother lists its sergers at 1, 5 and 25 years.
Singer lists its warranty terms model by model: 1, 5 and 25 years on the Quantum Stylist 9960, and 90 days, 2 years and 25 years on the S0100 serger. Its warranty document says which parts each term covers.
On a computerized machine more of what you use every day is electronic, so the short electronics term matters more. Brother may not cover machines sold by anyone other than an authorized reseller, so check the seller before you order, whichever brand you choose. See computerized vs mechanical for more on this.
Which brand should you pick?
Pick Brother if
- You want a light computerized machine with a speed slider for slow practice.
- You plan to quilt and want the walking foot and wide table in the box.
- You want the simplest first serger with color-coded threading.
Pick Singer if
- You sew denim and canvas often and want a stronger motor and metal frame.
- You want hundreds of stitches, lettering and many buttonhole styles.
- You want a serger with 2-thread stitches and a lever for rolled hems.
Still deciding between dials and a screen? Start with computerized vs mechanical sewing machines, or see our best sewing machines by job.
Specifications and manuals
Check the manufacturer’s model details and included accessories:
- Brother XM2701
- Singer Heavy Duty 4423
- Brother CS7000X
- Singer Quantum Stylist 9960
- Brother 1034D
- Singer S0100 serger
Our recommendations use published information, not hands-on testing. How we evaluate machines. Report a correction.